We spend much of our lives working toward a future in which we won’t have to work quite so hard. We save for retirement, look forward to vacations, dream about having more time for ourselves, and imagine all the things we’d do if we weren’t so busy making a living.
And yet, when that freedom finally arrives, some people discover they don’t know what to do with it.
Retirement offers an interesting glimpse into this paradox. Some people flourish when they’re finally free from the obligations of work. Others struggle with the loss of routine, identity, responsibility, or the feeling that they’re contributing something meaningful. Some return to work, not because they need the money, but because they miss having a reason to get up in the morning.
Retirement isn’t a perfect comparison, of course. Growing older brings its own challenges, and retiring from a working society is quite different from living in one where work itself has become largely optional. Still, it suggests something worth considering: having more time isn’t the same thing as knowing what to do with it.
In an earlier essay, When Nothing Needs to Be Done, I explored the possibility that artificial intelligence, robotics, and technological abundance might eventually free humanity from much of the economic necessity that has shaped civilization. Whether that freedom is broadly shared will depend on choices about ownership, access, and how the benefits are distributed. But suppose, for the sake of argument, that we eventually get those choices mostly right.
What happens when we no longer need to accomplish anything to survive, but still need to feel that our lives matter?
The Difference Between Mattering and Mattering More
Much of our adult lives is organized around responsibilities. We work to support ourselves, provide for the people who depend on us, and build some security for the future. Family, friendships, faith, and personal interests can give us direction independent of employment, but work occupies so much of our time that it becomes entangled with our identity.
Ask someone what they do, and they’ll usually tell you what they do for a living.
There’s nothing wrong with that. Work can be deeply satisfying. But when its rewards become inseparable from our occupations, it’s easy to lose sight of the different things we’re actually seeking.
Three of them deserve particular attention. Purpose gives us something to pursue, whether that’s raising a family, mastering a skill, or solving a difficult problem. Significance is the sense that we matter to other people and to the world, through our relationships and our contributions. Status concerns our standing relative to others.
Recognition sits somewhere between significance and status. It’s other people’s acknowledgment of what we’ve done, and it isn’t necessarily competitive. A friend’s gratitude or a child’s affection can affirm that we’ve made a difference without placing us above anyone. But recognition becomes something else when we begin measuring our worth by our position relative to others.
We usually pursue all of these at once, which makes them hard to separate, and they don’t always point in the same direction.
Consider a teacher who spends thirty years in the same middle school classroom. She may never receive much public recognition or rise to a prestigious position. Yet at her retirement party, a hundred former students might each remember a different sentence she said to them. Her significance is hard to measure and hard to dispute, and it has little to do with where she stands compared with anyone else.
There’s a difference between wanting our lives to matter and needing them to matter more than someone else’s.
The first doesn’t require a winner. The second does.
Comparison itself isn’t the problem. We learn from people who are better than we are, and shared standards help us grow. The trouble starts when comparison stops guiding our growth and begins determining our worth.
If technological abundance removes many of the practical reasons we compete, how much of our remaining ambition will depend on that difference?
The Things Abundance Cannot Provide
Imagine a future in which AI and robotics make most manufactured goods and essential services extraordinarily inexpensive. Beautiful homes, excellent healthcare, reliable transportation, and comforts that once required substantial wealth become widely accessible.
That wouldn’t eliminate every constraint. Desirable land, unique objects, and certain experiences would remain limited. But if most people enjoyed an extraordinary standard of living, possessions would become less useful as measures of success. A luxury car communicates something different when nearly everyone can afford one.
The desire for distinction, however, may prove harder to eliminate than the scarcity of goods.
Economist Fred Hirsch described positional goods, whose value depends partly on how they compare with what others possess. A prestigious position, an exclusive membership, or a first-place ranking cannot simply be multiplied until everyone has one. Their exclusivity is part of what makes them desirable.
Other things we value work differently. Love, friendship, affection, and genuine respect can’t be manufactured or guaranteed, but neither are they fixed in supply. One person’s friendship doesn’t diminish anyone else’s, and a person can be important to many people without making anyone less important.
That’s an important distinction. It means significance, unlike status, doesn’t have to be competitive.
It also raises an uncomfortable possibility. After satisfying nearly every material need, we may become more preoccupied with the forms of distinction that remain.
We can already glimpse this among people who no longer need to earn a living. Some devote their time to family, philanthropy, travel, or personal interests. Others keep building businesses, accumulating wealth, or pursuing influence long after they have more than enough.
Those choices don’t prove that status is the motive. Someone can keep working because they love creating things or feel responsible for the people who depend on them, and people who become exceptionally wealthy may be unusually driven to begin with.
Still, their behavior challenges the assumption that ambition fades once material needs are met. Abundance may reduce some forms of competition while intensifying others. When possessions stop distinguishing us, recognition, influence, and exclusive experiences could become even more desirable.
Or freedom from economic pressure could let more people stop measuring themselves against each other.
The Pleasure of Getting Better
Think about the things people choose to do even when there’s no practical reason to do them. Learning an instrument, playing a sport, mastering a craft, or spending years becoming a better dancer. None of these pursuits necessarily provides an income or leads to recognition, yet people willingly devote enormous amounts of time and effort to them.
The satisfaction often comes from the challenge itself.
In sports, someone else’s abilities can help us improve. In cycling, a difficult climb can be rewarding even when there’s no race to win. And in partner dancing, technique and skill certainly matter, but some of the most memorable experiences have little to do with who is the better dancer.
Sometimes it’s simply the music and the connection between two people.
Even so, comparison never entirely disappears. We recognize our improvement partly because we can do things that were once difficult, and partly because we can see skills in others that we haven’t yet developed. Communities establish standards, and those standards help us grow.
The line between personal mastery and competition is blurrier than it first appears.
The philosopher Bernard Suits explored a related puzzle in The Grasshopper, which imagines a world where practical necessity has largely disappeared and asks what people would do with themselves. His answer is that they would play games, which he defined as voluntarily accepting unnecessary obstacles.
Golf is a useful illustration. Getting a ball into a hole would be far easier if we simply carried it there, but doing so would eliminate the challenge that makes the game worth playing.
We spend much of our history inventing ways to make life easier, then devote our spare time to making things hard again. There’s no contradiction in that. The difficulty is part of what we value.
When Machines Become Better Than We Are
There’s another complication that makes this future different from retirement or inherited wealth. AI may not simply relieve us of work. It may eventually outperform us at many of the activities through which we’ve established our value.
For centuries, exceptional ability has brought recognition. We admire scientists who make discoveries, engineers who solve difficult problems, artists who create extraordinary work, and athletes who accomplish things most people cannot.
What happens when machines surpass us in many of those fields?
Chess offers a useful example. Computers overtook the strongest human players decades ago, yet people still study the game, follow tournaments, admire grandmasters, and compete for championships. Part of what we appreciate is the human accomplishment itself, a person working within the limits of human ability.
Physical strength offers another example. Machines took over much of the heavy physical work humans once performed, yet strength never stopped being admired. We still celebrate it in sports and other pursuits where the person’s effort is what matters.
Something similar may happen as AI becomes more capable.
In fields where we primarily value the results, such as drug discovery, engineering, and business, we may care less about whether a human performed every step. But in activities where the human performance is central, such as sports, music, dance, and craftsmanship, the accomplishment may remain just as meaningful.
In fact, those activities might become even more competitive as people look for ways to distinguish themselves in a world where machines can do so much.
That could mean competition for recognition becomes concentrated in fewer areas, potentially making the desire to stand out even stronger.
It also forces us to separate two things we’ve rarely had to consider independently: the value of an outcome and the value of being the person who produces it.
Someone may still spend years learning piano even though an AI can generate beautiful music instantly. Someone may study astronomy for the pleasure of understanding the universe even if an AI can answer every question faster.
Those pursuits provide purpose and pleasure. They can also create significance when they touch someone else’s life, whether it’s playing music at a friend’s wedding or helping a child discover the planets.
But they don’t necessarily satisfy the desire to be admired, influential, or exceptional. And for people whose identities depend heavily on those rewards, a world of increasingly capable machines could be unsettling.
We may have more opportunities than ever to pursue what interests us, while finding fewer ways to demonstrate that we’re better at it than everyone else.
Whether that feels liberating or threatening may depend on what we were seeking from achievement all along.
Enough to Matter
If AI performs much of the work we’ve relied on for income, identity, and recognition, it may force us to reconsider what we were pursuing all along.
Purpose can come from what we choose to do, whether or not anyone needs us to do it. Significance can come from the people we affect and the relationships we build. One person’s significance doesn’t have to diminish anyone else’s.
Neither requires us to stand above anyone.
Status is different. There will always be someone more accomplished, more admired, or more talented at something. And if our sense of worth depends on staying ahead, no amount of abundance can guarantee we’ll feel we have enough.
I don’t know whether a future of extraordinary abundance would make us less competitive or simply give us new things to compete over. Human nature is too complicated, and our relationship with achievement too deeply ingrained, for an easy prediction.
But I suspect the distinction between mattering and mattering more will become increasingly difficult to ignore.
I think partner dancing offers a small glimpse of what that distinction feels like. There’s skill involved, of course, and the satisfaction of improving is part of the appeal. But every so often, something else happens.
You find yourself dancing with someone where the connection just works. You’re both responding to the music and to each other, without having to think about what comes next. The movement feels natural, almost effortless, and everything outside that shared experience begins to fade.
For those few minutes, there’s no audience to impress, no ranking to consider, and no particular accomplishment to pursue. There’s just your partner, the music, and the experience you’re creating together.
And in that moment, it doesn’t matter who the best dancer in the room is.


